Category Archives: Valuations

Delaware Chancery Court Determines Fair Value of Minority Interest Buyout—Cites Differences in Cash-Flow Assumptions as Cause for Large Discrepancy in Value

August 30, 2023 | Court Rulings, Valuations

Ramcell, Inc. v Alltel Corp., 2022 Del. In this appraisal action to determine fair value, petitioner Ramcell Inc. exercised its appraisal rights in asking for a statutory appraisal of the value of its 155 shares of Jackson Cellular Telephone Co. Inc. The respondent, Alltel Corp. (dba Verizon Wireless), had converted the 155 shares at a  Continue Reading »

U.S. District Court in California Grants in Part and Denies in Part Motions of Dismissal by Company Against Blockchain Researcher

August 16, 2023 | Court Rulings, Valuations

Zamfir v CasperLabs, LLC The defendant, Casper Labs LLC, in this trademark dispute in U.S. District Court (California) moved for dismissal of eight causes of action from plaintiff Vlad Zamfir’s second amended complaint. The actions dealt primarily with trademark infringement and alleged damages therefrom. The actions also included allegations of fraud and misrepresentation under California  Continue Reading »

Connecticut Court Determines Fair Value of 50% Interest in Commercial Real Estate Holding Company—Parties Could Not Agree on Value

June 21, 2023 | Court Rulings, Valuations

Buccieri v. New Hope Realty, Inc. This case arose out of a dispute between the surviving family and a trustee of the founders of New Hope Realty Inc. The parties could not agree on the management and operations of New Hope Realty. On July 7, 2020, a dissolution proceeding was commenced. The defendants elected to  Continue Reading »

Arizona Appeals Court Affirms Trial Court’s Acceptance of a Calculation of Value

March 30, 2023 | Court Rulings, Valuations

Mikalacki v. Rubezic This Arizona divorce appeal affirmed the trial court’s acceptance of a calculation of value the wife’s expert, Brendan Kennedy, offered to determine the value of the couple’s law firm awarded to the husband in the trial. The husband appealed other nonvaluation issues related to the divorce, which the trial court affirmed. Those  Continue Reading »

Plaintiff Fails to Convince the Court That Physical Loss or Physical Damage Has Occurred; Virus Clause Applies and Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss Is Granted

December 13, 2021 | Court Rulings, Valuations

Family Tacos, LLC v. Auto Owners Ins. Co. Summary In this business interruption case resulting from mandatory shutdowns to control COVID-19, the court grants a motion to dismiss the plaintiff’s claims. Plaintiff operates two restaurants in Ohio, which has incurred losses due to the pandemic. Because the policy, as a matter of law, does not  Continue Reading »

Connecticut Supreme Court Clarifies Double-Counting Rule

September 21, 2021 | Court Rulings, Valuations

Oudheusden v. Oudheusden The Connecticut Supreme Court clarified this jurisdiction’s approach to double counting (or double-dipping in a recent decision). The court acknowledged that it had never been asked to determine whether the rule against double counting applied where the case involved the distribution of the value of the owner’s business and the consideration of  Continue Reading »

Indiana Supreme Court Rejects Blanket Rule Against Discounts in Compulsory, Closed-Market Share Buyback

September 8, 2021 | Court Rulings, Valuations

Hartman v. BigInch Fabricators & Construction Holding Co., Inc In 2020, the Indiana Court of Appeals overturned the trial court and found for the selling shareholder when it decided discounts were inappropriate in any compulsory, closed-market sale. The court did not think it mattered that a shareholder agreement specified a buyout based on specific valuation  Continue Reading »

Court Finds Valuation of Debtor Entity Must Account for COVID-19 Effect on Industry

August 9, 2021 | Valuations

A recent Chapter 11 bankruptcy ruling on the creditor’s election to treat its claim fully secured turned on valuation issues. On a basic level, the question was how to value a fitness club in the context of COVID-19 and the resulting economic uncertainty. The parties’ valuation experts disagreed about the extent to which they considered  Continue Reading »

Court Declines Motion to Dismiss Claim of Coverage for Loss of Income but dismisses the Claim of Coverage Under the Civil Authority Provision

July 26, 2021 | Court Rulings, Uncategorized, Valuations

Derek Scott Williams PLLC v. Cincinnati Ins. Co. Summary In this business interruption case resulting from mandatory shutdowns to control COVID-19, the court declined to grant a motion to dismiss the claim of the plaintiff as to coverage for loss of business income but does dismiss the claim of coverage under the civil authority provision  Continue Reading »

Expert’s Failure to Review Debtor’s Reorganization Plan Results in ‘Defective’ Hotel Appraisals

July 12, 2021 | Court Rulings, Uncategorized, Valuations

The key issue in the bankruptcy proceedings involving a debtor entity that owned two hotels was the value of the hotels, which would control the amount of the main creditor’s secured and unsecured claims. The valuation date was October 2020, a point when the effect of COVID-19 was keenly felt, particularly in the hospitality industry.  Continue Reading »