In re Horsehead Holding Corp., 2016 Bankr. LEXIS 3187 (May 2, 2016) Shareholders in a bankrupt company rarely get to form an equity committee that represents their interests during the reorganization proceedings. But, in an extraordinary bankruptcy case, the court, after hearing shareholders express concern over the valuations of the company, ordered the formation of  Continue Reading »

Let’s say that Maine Delicious Lobster Company loses its contract to deliver lobster for its primary customer, Good Maine Sandwich Company. Furthermore, the contract loss was due to an alleged breach by Good Maine Sandwich Company. The lobster company sues the sandwich company for damages. Or wait, should Good Maine Sandwich Company sue for loss of business value?  Continue Reading »

Post-Confirmation Comm. for Small Loans, Inc. v. Martin, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 44270 (March 31, 2016) A recent ruling in a complex bankruptcy case teaches that Daubert can accommodate differing views on determining solvency for multiple debtor entities. Consolidated vs. stand-alone basis A group of related family-run consumer lending and retail businesses filed for Chapter  Continue Reading »

Currently under the federal income tax rules, legal expenses incurred by individuals are typically not deductible. Instead, they’re most often treated as either part of the cost of acquiring an asset, such as real estate, or as personal outlays (which are nondeductible). In the acquiring asset situation, legal costs usually aren’t deductible right away; instead, they  Continue Reading »

Fish v. Greatbanc Trust Co., 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 137351 (Sept. 1, 2016) In an important ESOP decision, the court dismissed claims that the defendants had committed breaches of fiduciary duty and engaged in a prohibited transaction. The case turned on the soundness of the fairness and valuation opinions a nationally recognized valuation firm had  Continue Reading »

Business valuations are prepared for many purposes Maine, including litigation, estate and gift tax, and the purchase or sale of a business. They can be an essential part of all of these things, and it is important to properly understand and utilize a valuation.  At Filler & Associates, we recommend that the reader critically review  Continue Reading »

Kminek-Nierenberg v. Kenneth Nierenberg, 2016 N.J. Super. Unpub. LEXIS 2015 (Sept. 8, 2016) A complex New Jersey divorce litigation with multiple defendants and several family businesses illustrates the challenges appraisers and the trial court faced in determining the appreciated value of numerous separate premarital and gifted assets for equitable distribution purposes. The case highlights basic  Continue Reading »

Traditional valuation models don’t necessarily work for Maine small businesses and professional practices. Public market data may be less relevant for a small business that functions primarily as a job or steady source of income its owner(s). Instead, business appraisers and brokers typically recommend using an alternate metric for appraising small businesses known as “seller’s discretionary  Continue Reading »

MSKP Oak Grove, LLC v. Venuto, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 84950 (June 29, 2016) A recent fraud case illustrates how a thorough expert report can help an embattled valuator stay the course even in the tumult of litigation. The key is to document everything. Need for reverse engineering Four defendants sold their tanning salon franchise  Continue Reading »

Congel v Malfitano, 2016 N.Y. App. Div. LEXIS 3706 (May 18, 2016) What a difference a word makes. That’s the lesson from a recent New York appellate ruling in a dispute in which a minority shareholder was found liable of wrongfully breaching the partnership agreement to secure a high price in the buyout of his  Continue Reading »